|Year : 2014 | Volume
| Issue : 6 | Page : 356-361
The efficacy of relaxation training on stress, anxiety, and pain perception in hemodialysis patients
MA Heidari Gorji1, A Abbaskhani Davanloo2, AM Heidarigorji3
1 Department of Nursing and Midwifery, Mazandaran Medical Science University, Sari, Iran
2 Department of Anesthesiology, Mazandaran University of Medical Science, Sari, Iran
3 Education and Development Center, Mazandaran University of Medical Science, Sari, Iran
|Date of Web Publication||13-Nov-2014|
A M Heidarigorji
Education and Development Centre, Mazandaran Medical Science University, Sari
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Patients on dialysis experience psychological distress, which can impact pain perception. Reduction of stress and anxiety in patients provides psychological resources to cope with their physical condition. We examined the efficacy of relaxation training on stress, anxiety, and pain perception of hemodialysis (HD) patients. eighty HD patients were randomized into two groups (intervention and control). Benson relaxation training was implemented in the intervention group for 15 min twice daily during 4 weeks. Pain perception, stress, and anxiety scale were evaluated before and after intervention. There were significant differences between pain perception, stress, and anxiety levels in case group before and after intervention (P < 0.001) and there was a correlation between pain perception with stress and anxiety. Instructing Benson's relaxation technique is accompanied by reducing pain, stress, and anxiety level of HD patients. Reducing stress and anxiety can provide calmness for the patients so that pursuing medical therapy would be accompanied with more tranquility and low pain intensity. We suggest improving and preventing the patients' psychological problems as well as other chronic disorders through applying nonpharmacological interventions.
Keywords: Anxiety, Benson′s relaxation, pain perception, stress
|How to cite this article:|
Heidari Gorji M A, Davanloo A A, Heidarigorji A M. The efficacy of relaxation training on stress, anxiety, and pain perception in hemodialysis patients. Indian J Nephrol 2014;24:356-61
|How to cite this URL:|
Heidari Gorji M A, Davanloo A A, Heidarigorji A M. The efficacy of relaxation training on stress, anxiety, and pain perception in hemodialysis patients. Indian J Nephrol [serial online] 2014 [cited 2018 Aug 17];24:356-61. Available from: http://www.indianjnephrol.org/text.asp?2014/24/6/356/132998
| Introduction|| |
Chronic renal failure is a progressive and irreversible destruction of renal function.  Dialysis is a stressful process and follows various psychological and social problems, which can lead to psychological disturbances. Long term hemodialysis (HD) patients suffer from physical and mental stresses and experience serious changes in lifestyle and personality.  The prevalence of psychiatric hospitalization among patients who are on dialysis therapy is 1.5-3 times higher compared with other chronic diseases and adversely affects the quality of life. , In several studies, the high prevalence of psychological disorders has been reported. For example, Mollahadi et al., have reported that 63.9% of HD patients had anxiety, 60.5% had depression, and 51.7% had stress.
A variety of conditions have been reported including suicide ideation,  depression, anxiety, sexual disorders, interpersonal problems, paranoia, physical complain, compulsive disorders, psychoses, aggression, and phobia, the prevalence and intensity of these problems among HD patients is not uniform.  Navidian et al., revealed 10% of HD patients had a history of psychiatric disorders while this was only 2.5% in the general population. 
Stress refers to the consequence of the failure of a person to cope with emotional or physical threats.  Mental health is directly related to perceived stress.  Inappropriate coping in HD patients decreases quality-of-life  and lead to physical, mental, economic, social, and emotional problems.  On the other hand, these patients suffering from considerable pain. The potential sources of pain are numerous and varied, including such things as diabetic neuropathy, vascular access surgery, and degenerative joint disease associated with age. These sources also range from being chronic to acute conditions. It is known that the presence of chronic pain impacts upon the quality-of-life and can play a major role in the comorbidity of anxiety and depression.  Pharmacological methods are costly and may lead to complications. Nonpharmacological techniques as complementary methods can lead to improvement in a shorter time.  Relaxation is one of the most useful nonpharmacological techniques, , which reduce stress through impact on mental and physical conditions, depression, mood, anxiety, and self-steam.  Among relaxation methods Benson's relaxation method (1970) is one of the easiest to learn and administer.  Despite the importance of reduction of stress and anxiety among HD patients, there is no data on the impact of nonpharmacological methods on pain especially relaxation in HD patients in Iran. This study was designed to evaluate the impact of Benson's relaxation method of stress reduction of HD patients in Iran.
| Materials and Methods|| |
The present research was a randomized trial. The study population included all HD patients from Imam Khomeini and Fatemeh Zahra Hospitals in the Mazandaran city during 2011, which meet the inclusion criteria (N = 138). This study was approved by the Ethics Committees of Mazandaran Medical Science Universities. Eighty eight patients were selected randomly out of 138 patients based on a random number table. The samples divided into two groups: Experimental (N = 44) and control (N = 44) randomly through numbered table. Sampling was parallel the first eligible patients assigned randomly in the intervention group and the next one in the control group. This process applied to all samples. All samples who met inclusion criteria were selected and assigned randomly and had the same chance of participation. Sample selection was done during the week at 3 times, morning, afternoon, and evening.
The inclusion criteria were: Age range between 18 and 65; dialysis history at least 2 months; no comorbidity with other chronic disease such as cancer, heart disease, etc., (diabetes and hypertension were included). Exclusion criteria were unwillingness of a patient, physical disability, regular tranquillizer or sedative drugs; had a previous history of psychiatric disorders, suffered from stress other than dialysis in the past 6 months, incomplete training (below 55 sessions) and peritoneal dialysis or a kidney transplant. Sample size calculation was based on the pilot study as follows:
Assuming a mean and standard deviation before (16.5 ± 6.9) and after (13.13 ± 2.27) with 95% confidence level, sample size was calculated at N = 37 regarding prediction of a 10% drop during intervention N = 44 was final sample size.
The following demographic characteristics were included: Age, gender, marital status, income level, education level, dialysis time and duration, shelter status, medicine usage, other disease, etc.,
The stress and anxiety were assessed by depression anxiety stress scale (DASS21). The DASS is a quantitative measure of distress along the three axes of depression, anxiety, and stress. It is not a categorical measure of clinical diagnoses. Individual DASS scores do not define appropriate interventions.
This questionnaire had been presented for the first time by Lovibond in 1995  which included three subscales and every subscale included seven questions. In translated version each item has choices of never, little, moderate, and many. The lowest score is related to every zero question and the most score is three.  In this questionnaire, the questions 2, 4, 7, 9, 15, 19, and 20 are related to anxiety; the questions 3, 5, 10, 13, 16, 17, and 21 are related to depression, and the questions 1, 6, 8, 11, 12, 14, and 18 assess the stress. Based on the aims of this study, we have used anxiety and stress sections. Defined cut-off points are as follows:
Stress: Scores 0-7 is normal, 8-9 mild, 10-12 average, 13-16 sever, and higher than 17 is very serious
Anxiety: 0-3 is normal, 4-5 is mild, 6-7 is average, 8-9 sever, and higher than 10 is very severe. 
Validity and reliability of this questionnaire were fair in Iran. For instance in a study done by Sahebi et al., on 970 students and armies, the authors reported the translated questionnaire is comparable with the original one with high internal correlation 0.77, 0.79, and 0.78 for depression, anxiety, and stress, respectively.  Another study, in Iran, also been reported the Cronbach alpha of 0.94 for depression, 0.92 for anxiety, and 0.82 for stress. 
Pain was assessed using the short form McGill Pain Questionnaire (MPQ - McGill, Melzack, 1987). This three part questionnaire was self-administered with research staff support. Instructions were read out loud to participants by the research staff to make sure that they are fully understood and that participants understand the meaning of the adjective list words.
The main component consisted of 15 descriptive adjectives, 11 sensory including: Throbbing, shooting, stabbing, sharp, cramping, gnawing, hot-burning, aching, heavy, tender, splitting, and four affective including: Tiring-exhausting, sickening, fearful, punishing-cruel, which are rated by the patients according to their severity on a four point scale (0 = none, 1 = mild, 2 = moderate, 3 = severe), yielding three scores. The sensory and affective scores are calculated by adding sensory and affective item values separately, and the total score is the sum of the two above-mentioned scores. In this study, we just used pain rating index with total scores.
Adelmanesh et al., (2011) conducted a study in Iran to examine the validity and reliability of McGill's pain questionnaire. The internal consistency was found to be 0.951, 0.832, and 0.840 for sensory, affective, and total scores, respectively by Cronbach's alpha. Item to subscale score correlations supported the convergent validity of each item to its hypothesized subscale. Correlations were observed to range from r2 = 0.202 to r2 = 0.739. 
Depression anxiety stress scale-21 questionnaire was administrated by nurses blindly before and after intervention by self-reporting method or nurses recorded data in case they were illiterate or have visual disorders. After patients signed consent to participate, we used video exhibition to train the Benson relaxation method to patients and their caregivers in the dialysis center. In first step, the patients and their caregivers learned relaxation through the exhibition in HD center. Caregiver were instructed to guide patients to practice correctly a time twice a day morning and evening for 15 min during 4 weeks.  Relaxation was practiced whenever they attended center. They were also or contacted by phone daily to remind on timed practice. The instruction of the Benson relaxation technique included the following steps:
- Stay in confidence position
- Close your eyes
- Calm down and relax your body, relax from your toes to top of your head
- Take a breath from your nose and keep your awareness. Exhale from the mouth whenever exhaling repeat one word or number inhale and exhale comfort and confidence
- Do this for 15 min try to keep your body and muscles relax. Then open your eyes slowly and don't move for some minutes
- Don't worry it is not important to which level of relaxation you have reached leave your body and let it happen itself. Don't care about interfering thoughts and let them go. 
Data were analyzed using the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences software (SPSS, version 16.0, SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA). Descriptive statistics such as central and dispersion indexes were first run and independent sample t-test was applied to compare the two groups. Demographic data was categorized into quantities K squared used to analysis the obtained data. Pre- and post-intervention scores in each group were compared using the paired t-test. The Chi-square test was used to compare qualitative variables. The level of significance was defined as 0.05.
| Results|| |
Out of 88 patients, 80 completed at least 55 sessions and were included in analysis. The samples comprised 44 male (55%) and 36 females (45%) and age mean was 47.98 ± 12.53. The maximum age was 65 and minimum 18. Seventy-one people were married (88.8%), eight were single (10%), and one was (1.2%) [Table 1].
There was no significant difference in demographic characters between two groups. The comparison of two mean scores before and after intervention in terms of pain, stress, and anxiety showed a significant difference (P < 0.001). Amongst the control group, there was no significant difference in two time frame scores (P > 028, P > 0.11, and P > 0.18) [Table 2]. There was a correlation between pain and stress (r = 0.563), anxiety and pain (r = 0.489), age and pain (r = 0.268), anxiety and stress (r = 0.919), anxiety and age (r = 0.505), anxiety and dialysis duration (r = −279), anxiety and income (r = −0.299), stress and age (r = 0.393), stress and dialysis duration (r = −198), stress and income (r = −0.277) [Table 3].
|Table 2: The mean comparison between two groups stress, anxiety, and pain |
Click here to view
|Table 3: Correlation of pain, anxiety, stress, age, duration, and income |
Click here to view
| Discussion|| |
We found a high prevalence of stress, anxiety, and depression among patients on HD. There was significant differences in mean and standard deviation of control and intervention groups for stress and anxiety scores. Furthermore, there were significant correlation between anxiety, stress, and pain with age, duration, and income level (P > 0.05).
Same results have been reported by Dumitrescu,  Mollahadi,  Shafipour,  Eghbali,  and Rajamanicam  studies. They also suggested stress reduction influences the quality-of-life among the patients under HD through regular psychotherapy.
The results of this study highlighted Benson relaxation helped patients compared to those who did not receive any intervention. Meanwhile, the changes in stress scores were significant. There is growing evidence to evaluation of the influence of Benson relaxation as a cost-effective and safe technique on different chronic disease. ,,,,,,,, Hosseini et al., confirmed that psychological training based on the standard protocols and the use of medicine resulted in comparable decreases in the severity of depressive and anxiety symptoms of HD patients. 
In another study, Rahimi et al., evaluated palliative care effects during 4-6 months on stress, anxiety and depression and the results showed positive effects of care on HD patients.  Kim et al., also explored the effect of music therapy on stress, anxiety and depression in HD patients and confirmed significant stress reduction in HD patients after music therapy.  Carroll and Seers (1998) and Kwekkeboom and Gretarsdottir (2006) conducted a systematic review of the efficacy of relaxation techniques in both acute and chronic pain. Overall relaxation was found to have a significant effect on pain outcomes. Progressive muscle relaxation was found effective in reduction of pain sensation in several chronic pain conditions. ,
The findings of this study also showed that there is a relationship between pain and stress (r = 0.563), anxiety and pain (r = 0.489), age and pain (r = 0.268), anxiety and stress (r = 0.919), anxiety and age (r = 0.505), anxiety and dialysis duration (r = −279), anxiety and income (r = −0.299), stress and age (r = 0.393), stress and dialysis duration (r = −198), stress and income (r = −0.277). As it is obvious from results correlation between pain with stress and anxiety is positive. The high estimation of anxiety among patients with chronic disease is explainable with fear anxiety avoidance model.  While anxiety can cause pain, pain can also cause anxiety. Current fear-anxiety-avoidance models of chronic pain emphasize pain-related anxiety as a key diathesis for the development and maintenance of chronic pain. Several studies have shown those that live with chronic or recurring pain often develop anxiety disorders because of the constant stress which the pain puts on their body. 
Age and income were also correlated with pain, stress and anxiety. Takaki et al., (2005) showed that anxiety levels decreased when patients had both high income and demonstrated a range of task-oriented stress coping mechanisms. For patients undergoing HD for long duration or with a relatively high income, decreased anxiety accompanying a decrease of emotion-oriented stress, coping was greater as compared with other patients. 
The results of this study and other related studies in this context showed that using cost-effective, low risk and easy methods by patients could help the patients to reduce the stress and leads to several benefits if practiced daily beside the palliative cares and alternative treatments in HD patients. Regarding some limitation of this study, we could not observe all sessions there can be some inaccurate reporting from patients or caregivers. On the other hand, DASS21 is not a categorical measure of clinical diagnoses. The individual DASS scores do not define appropriate interventions. Therefore, using complementary tools is recommended for future studies.
| Conclusion|| |
Our findings confirmed the effect of relaxation on stress and anxiety which was reported in several studies. In the most of studies, the recommendations emphasize on long and regular practice. Thus, with education of nurses and patients can benefit them with the low cost and prevent from extra problems as it is easy to use and teach to all of patients.
| Acknowledgment|| |
We acknowledge the staff and patients cooperation with researchers in Emam Khomeini and Fatima Zahra Hospitals of Sari.
| References|| |
Zamanzade V, Heydarzade M, Ashvandi K, Lak D. Relationship between quality of life and social support in hemodialysis patient. Med J Tabriz Univ Sci 2007;7:49-54.
Ibrahim K, Taboonpong S, Nilmanat K. Coping and quality of life among Indonesians undergoing hemodialysis. Thai J Nurs Res 2009;2:109-17.
Chen CK, Tsai YC, Hsu HJ, Wu IW, Sun CY, Chou CC, et al
. Depression and suicide risk in hemodialysis patients with chronic renal failure. Psychosomatics 2010;51:528-5286. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21051686.
Ghaffari A. Renal transplantation two-days seminar. J Med Eng Tehran 2007;8:37.
Kimmel PL. Psychosocial factors in dialysis patients. Kidney Int 2001;59:1599-613.
Navidian A, Arbabisarjou A, Kikhai A. Frequency of mental disturbances in hemodialysis patients referred to hemodialysis ward of Khatam-Al-Anbia Hospital in Zahedan. J Guilan Univ Med Sci 2006;15:61-7.
Niazi AK, Niazi SK. Mindfulness-based stress reduction: A non-pharmacological approach for chronic illnesses. N Am J Med Sci 2011;3:20-3.
Baykan H, Yargic I. Depression, anxiety disorders, quality of life and stress coping strategies in hemodialysis and continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis patients. Bull Clin Psychopharmacol 2012;22:167-76.
Mirzaei M, Azymyan M. Study on neurological complications in dialysis patients. Iran J Neurol 2009;8:458-64.
Borzou SR, Ghlyaf M, Amini R, Zandieh M, Turkman B. The effect of increasing blood flow rate on dialysis adequacy in hemodialysis patients. J Shahrekord Univ Med Sci 2006;8:60-6.
Steven A. Coping with pain: The dialysis patient′s perspective. J Nephrol Soc Work 2003;2:42-4.
Nejad NB. Psychosocial stressors in hemodialized patients of Qazvin. J Qazin Univ Med Sci 2000;4:90-5.
Shafipour V, Jafari H, Shafipour L. The relationship between stress intensity and life quality in hemodialysis patients hospitalized in Sari Iran (2008). Quarterly J Sabzevar Uni Med Sci 2009;16:155-60.
Bagheri Nesami M, Mohammadi E, Sadeghi R. Effect of Benson relaxation on the rate of disease process in rheumatoid patients referring to rheumatology research center of Imam Khomeini hospital in Tehran in 2000-2001. J Mazandaran Univ Med Sci 2003;13:22-8.
Craven R, Hirnle C. Fundamental of Nursing: Human Health and Function. Philadelphia: Lippincott Co.; 2000. p. 1309.
Reilly CM. Relaxation: A concept analysis. Graduate Research Nursing. 2000. [Accessed June 23, 2003]. at http://www.graduateresearch.com/grntoc3.htm.
Lovibond PF. Long-term stability of depression, anxiety, and stress syndromes. J Abnorm Psychol 1998;107:520-6.
Homayouni K, Zaher H, Borhani F, Abbaszadeh A, Motamed Jahromi M. Effect of tactile touch on stress in patients with myocardial infarction. Iran J Crit Care Nurs 2012;5:182-7.
Monahan F, Sands J, Nighbors M, Marek J, Green C. Complementary and alternative therapies. Text Book of Phipp′s, Medical-Surgical Nursing. 8 th
ed. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams and Wilkins ; 2007. p. 55-7.
Sahebi A, Asghari MJ, Salari R. Validation of depression, anxiety and stress (DASS-21) for Iranian population. Iran Psychol 2005;1:50-60.
Moradi Panah F. The effect of music on stress, anxiety and depression in patients undergoing cardiac catheterization in Tarbiat Modarres University; 2005.
AbedSaeedi J, Salmi S. Stress management and nursing interventions. Textbook of Medical-Surgical Bruner, Biophysical and Psychosocial Concepts in Nursing. Initial Edition. Salemi: Arjmand; 2001. p. 35-7.
Adelmanesh F, Arvantaj A, Rashki H, Ketabchi S, Montazeri A, Raissi G. Results from the translation and adaptation of the Iranian Short-Form McGill Pain Questionnaire (I-SF-MPQ): Preliminary evidence of its reliability, construct validity and sensitivity in an Iranian pain population. Sports Med Arthrosc Rehabil Ther Technol 2011;3:27.
Dumitrescu AL, Gârneaþã L, Guzun O. Anxiety, stress, depression, oral health status and behaviours in Romanian hemodialysis patients. Rom J Intern Med 2009;47:161-8.
Eghbali M, Shahqolian N, Nazari F, Babaee S. Comparing problems of patients with chronic renal failure undergoing hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis referring to medical university′s hospitals. Iran J Nurs Midwifery Res 2009;14:15.
Rajamanickam T, Kumar U. Assessment of stress and coping ability among patients subjected to hemodialysis in a tertiary care center. SRMM College of Nursing; 2008. (Virginia Henderson-International Nursing Library).
Kiyani CH, Kermanshahi SM, Ahmadi F. Study of the effect of Benson′s relaxation technique on hemodynamic parameters and stress of discharge in acute myocardial infarction patients in Tehran, 2002. J Shahid Sadoughi Univ Med Sci Health Serv 2003;11:50-6.
Hanifi N, Ahmadi F, Memarian R, Khani M. Comparative study on two methods, Benson relaxation Vs premeditation, and their effect on respiratory rate and pulse rate of patients experiencing coronary angiography. HAYAT 2005;11:47-54.
Nikbakht Nasrabadi A, Larijani TT, Mahmoudi M, Taghlili F. A comparative study of the effect of Benson′s relaxation technique and Zekr (rosary) on the anxiety level of patients awaiting abdominal surgery. HAYAT 2004;10:29-37.
Hazrati M, Hoseini M, Dejbakhsh T, Taghavi SA, Rajaee-fard A. The effect of Benson relaxation therapy on anxiety level and severity of symptoms in patients with irritable bowel syndrome. AMUJ 2006; 9(4): 9-17.
Aghebati N, Mohammadi I, Pour Esmaeil Z. The effect of relaxation on anxiety and stress of patients with cancer during hospitalization. J Nurs Midwifery 2010;23:15-22.
Fayazi S, Shariati A, Momeni M, Latifi M. The efficacy of Benson′s relaxation technique on postoperative pain in coronary artery bypasses graft. Sci Med J 2010; 8(4);479-489.
Pourmemari MH. A study of the effect the Benson relaxation technique on anxiety and cardiac dysrhythmias in cardiac catheterization. Sci J Zanjan 1994;13:40-49.
Hosseini SH, Espahbodi F, Mirzadeh Goudarzi SM. Citalopram versus psychological training for depression and anxiety symptoms in hemodialysis patients. Iran J Kidney Dis 2012;6:446-51.
Rahimi A, Ahmadi F, Gholyaf M. Effects of applying continuous care model (CCM) on stress, anxiety and depression in hemodialysis patients. J Shahid Beheshti Univ Med Sci 2007;30:353-9.
Kim KB, Lee MH, Sok SR. The effect of music therapy on anxiety and depression in patients undergoing hemodialysis. Taehan Kanho Hakhoe Chi 2006;36:321-9.
Carroll D, Seers K. Relaxation for the relief of chronic pain: A systematic review. J Adv Nurs 1998;27:476-87.
Kwekkeboom KL, Gretarsdottir E. Systematic review of relaxation interventions for pain. J Nurs Scholarsh 2006;38:269-77.
Vlaeyen JW, Linton SJ. Fear-avoidance and its consequences in chronic musculoskeletal pain: A state of the art. Pain 2000;85:317-32.
Leeuw M, Goossens ME, Linton SJ, Crombez G, Boersma K, Vlaeyen JW. The fear-avoidance model of musculoskeletal pain: Current state of scientific evidence. J Behav Med 2007;30:77-94.
Takaki J, Nishi T, Shimoyama H, Inada T, Matsuyama N, Kumano H, et al
. Possible interactive effects of demographic factors and stress coping mechanisms on depression and anxiety in maintenance hemodialysis patients. J Psychosom Res 2005;58:217-23.
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3]